Book Review - The History of White People - By Nell Irvin Painter - Review

Media_httpgraphics8ny_bfbie

Concept explication at it's finest: "White" turns out to be a variable, as of course do other "categories" of the construct ethnicity. Amazing, right? The more you think about all of this, the more confusing and and irritating it is. This is why using categorical variables is always questionable: The implication is that there is more homogeneity within categories of ethnicity than between them. I doubt that this is true today in the US, where waves of immigration mixed the various flavors of "white" (see above) with the so-called "minority" categories of ethnicity. Do you think there was more homogeneity within ethnic categories 100 years ago than today? 50 years ago? And so, is there anything to be gained by using the concept "ethnicity" in social science research today?

Pamela Shoemaker

Pamela Shoemaker

I'm a Mass Comm Scholar. What about you?

I hold an endowed research chair at Syracuse University and am the John Ben Snow Professor, S.I. Newhouse School of Public Communications, Syracuse NY, USA, 1-315-443-9255. I teach research methods & theory. I study influences on media content, gatekeeping, cross-cultural news and news values, definitions of newsworthiness, news on multiple platforms.

My recent books include:
-- Gatekeeping Theory (with Tim Vos)
-- News Around the World (with Akiba Cohen)
-- How to Build Social Science Theory (with Jim Tankard and Nick Lasorsa)
-- Mediating the Message (with Steve Reese); 3rd edition under way

please feel free to comment here and to email me at snowshoe@syr.edu. thanks, pam

Archive

2011 (41)
2010 (63)
2009 (30)
Posterous theme by Cory Watilo